Is It Worth Keeping the Zachary Taylor Dollar? A Guide to Coin’s Long-Term Potential

An elderly coin collector smiles as he holds a pristine Zachary Taylor dollar in gloved hands, flipping through his coin album.

When the dollar coin with the image of Zack Taylor, the twelfth president of the United States, appeared in circulation, many people did not pay much attention to it. For most people, it was just a piece of change, quickly forgotten after being handed in at the store. 

However, among collectors this coin earned its place in the series of presidential dollars, and now more people are interested in how Zachary Taylor dollar coin value changes over time and whether this coin has investment potential?

So, today we will together explore how much the Zachary Taylor dollar is really worth, what factors influence its price, how to distinguish valuable specimens and whether it is worth keeping such a coin in your collection.

An elderly coin collector smiles as he holds a pristine Zachary Taylor dollar in gloved hands, flipping through his coin album.

Who Was Zachary Taylor and Why Is He on the Dollar?

Zachary Taylor may not be the most talked-about U.S. president, but his legacy is far from forgettable. Before his political career, he was best known as a tough and respected general in the Mexican-American War. Nicknamed “Old Rough and Ready,” Taylor’s battlefield leadership earned him national fame — enough to launch him straight into the White House without prior political experience.

Although his presidency lasted only 16 months before his untimely death in 1850, Taylor was remembered as a symbol of military strength and national unity. That legacy secured his place in the Presidential $1 Coin Program, a series launched by the U.S. Mint to honor each president in order of service from 2007 to 2016.

The Zachary Taylor dollar coin was released in 2009, and it stands out for several reasons:

  • Commemorates the 160th anniversary of Taylor’s death, giving it added historical significance.
  • Features a detailed portrait of Taylor on the obverse (front), designed to reflect his firm character.
  • Displays the Statue of Liberty on the reverse — a standard image across all coins in the Presidential series.
  • Edge lettering includes the year of issue, mint mark, “E Pluribus Unum,” and “In God We Trust,” making it visually distinct from traditional coins.

Though modern and often overlooked, this coin represents more than just a dollar — it is a compact tribute to a short-lived but impactful presidency.

Technical Characteristics of the Zachary Taylor Dollar Coin

Even modern coins carry collectible value — especially when they are part of a historically themed series like the Presidential dollars. Whether you’re checking for errors, planning to store the coin properly, or just curious about what you’re holding, the technical specifications of the Zachary Taylor dollar coin offer important clues.

Here’s a breakdown of its key characteristics:

SpecificationDetails
Denomination$1
CompositionManganese-brass (88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, 2% nickel)
Weight8.1 grams
Diameter26.5 mm
EdgeLettered
Edge Inscriptions“In God We Trust,” “E Pluribus Unum,” year, mint mark
Obverse DesignPortrait of Zachary Taylor
Reverse DesignStatue of Liberty
Year of Issue2009

Tip: One detail to always check is the edge lettering. Some coins from this series — including a few Taylor dollars — have been discovered with missing or doubled inscriptions, turning an ordinary coin into a collectible worth several times its face value.

What Is the Zachary Taylor Dollar Worth Today?

While it may seem like just another golden-colored coin, the Zachary Taylor Presidential Dollar can be worth more than its face value — especially in the right condition or with the right features.

Below is a breakdown of its typical market value:

  • Circulated coins usually sell for $1.00 to $2.00, depending on wear and visibility of details.
  • Uncirculated coins (especially those stored properly since 2009) can reach $3.00 to $5.00.
  • Proof versions — struck with extra care and sold in official Mint sets — often sell for $4.00 to $7.00, depending on condition and packaging.
  •  Rare errors, such as missing or doubled edge inscriptions, can skyrocket the price. Some have sold for $50 and up, particularly when authenticated by grading services.

Tip: Want to know exactly what your Zachary Taylor dollar is worth right now? Use the Coin ID Scanner app — it analyzes your coin using a photo and helps detect historical background and hidden errors or condition issues that can affect its value.

 A young woman scans a Zachary Taylor dollar coin with her smartphone at the kitchen table, carefully examining its features.

Key Factors That Affect Long-Term Value

Not all Zachary Taylor dollars are created equal. Whether you’re collecting casually or eyeing long-term value, several important factors can influence how much your coin might be worth in the future:

  1. Condition (Grade)

The better the coin’s condition, the higher its potential value. Coins graded MS-65 or higher are especially sought-after by collectors and can fetch a premium price.

  1. Mintage Figures

How many were made? The U.S. Mint struck a substantial number in 2009, but scarcity can still arise based on demand:

MintMintage
Philadelphia (P)41,580,000
Denver (D)36,680,000
San Francisco (S, Proof)~2,800,000

Despite the large numbers, only a fraction of these survive in pristine, collectible condition — especially with edge inscriptions intact.

  1. Minting Errors

Although rare, errors such as missing lettering on the edge or doubled inscriptions make certain coins far more valuable. These varieties are highly sought after and should always be authenticated.

  1. Collector Interest

The Presidential $1 Coin series is increasingly appreciated by collectors trying to complete the entire set. As more people join the hobby or revisit the series, demand for overlooked coins like the Taylor dollar can rise.

Tip: Focus your efforts on proof coins and high-grade uncirculated examples (MS65+) — they are more likely to increase in value over time, especially if stored carefully and certified.

Why the Zachary Taylor Dollar Is More Than “Just Another Coin”

At first glance, the Zachary Taylor dollar may seem like just another modern commemorative. But don’t be too quick to dismiss it — this coin holds hidden potential, both historical and financial.

Here is why collectors are starting to pay closer attention:

  • It’s part of a completed and closed series — the Presidential Dollar Program ended in 2016, making it a finite collectible line. Completed sets tend to increase in value, especially when demand grows.
  • Potential appreciation: As time passes, collectors and historians alike place more value on coins tied to specific eras. With the 250th anniversary of the U.S. approaching in 2026, there’s renewed interest in coins that honor American leadership and history.
  • No longer in circulation: Since 2012, Presidential $1 coins — including new releases — have been struck only for collectors, not for general circulation. That means coins like Taylor’s 2009 release are becoming more desirable simply because they’re no longer as easily found in everyday change.

Interesting fact: The 2009 Zachary Taylor dollar was part of the last few coins in the series that were widely released into circulation. That makes early Presidential dollars like his more accessible now, but likely harder to find in the future.

 Should You Invest or Just Hold On?

So, you’ve got a Zachary Taylor dollar coin in your hands — what now? Should you treat it as a casual collectible or stash it away like a future treasure?

Here is a simple breakdown to help guide your decision:

  • Circulated coins in average condition are typically worth just around face value. These are best enjoyed as part of a casual or educational collection.
  • Uncirculated coins or error varieties deserve more attention. If your coin still shines with its original mint luster or has a visible error (like a missing edge inscription), it’s a smart move to store it safely and monitor its market value over time.
  • Proof coins and those graded MS65 or higher are excellent candidates for long-term holding. These coins already carry a premium and could appreciate steadily as the Presidential Dollar series becomes more widely collected.

Tip: Proper storage is critical to protecting your coin’s value. Use coin capsules, archival-quality folders, or acid-free albums to shield your dollar from oxidation, scratches, and environmental damage.

How and Where to Sell (If You Decide To)

If you are thinking about cashing in — either now or in the future — choosing the right platform and presentation is key to getting a good return.

Best Places to Sell:

  • Online marketplaces like eBay, Etsy, or specialized numismatic forums allow you to reach a wide collector audience.
  • Coin shows and local auctions can offer direct, in-person opportunities to negotiate with experienced buyers.
  • For rare errors or proof coins, consider professional dealers or grading services to authenticate and maximize value.

Pro tip: Whether you sell online or offline, take clear, high-resolution photos of your coin — especially the edge inscriptions, mint mark, and any errors. Include key info like year, grade (if known), and features in your listing. This can boost buyer interest by 30–50% and help your coin stand out from the crowd.

Hold or Let Go?

The Zachary Taylor dollar coin may not seem like a jackpot item at first glance, but in the world of numismatics, even modern coins can reveal unexpected value.

If your coin is circulated and common, it is a fun keepsake or an educational piece. But if you have a proof, high-grade, or error coin, it is wise to hold on and preserve it — especially with the upcoming 250th anniversary of U.S. independence on the horizon, which could renew interest in historical presidential coins.

Bottom line? Don’t rush to sell. Take the time to evaluate your coin’s true potential — and let history (and the market) work in your favor.